Customer Reviews

Read what some of our satisfied insurance customers have to say! If you’d like to provide your feedback, please submit your online review.

  • Peter Granata
    Prompt and accurate service, and very nice people to deal with.
  • Jacqui Murgas Borman
    I would highly recommend Selzer Insurance.

    “We began using Selzer Insurance over a year ago to help insure our business and our employees. Not only was Reenie Selzer knowledgeable and efficient, she spent the time to understand the needs for my business. She found us the same coverage and for less money than our previous agent. As a small business owner I appreciate the savings and more so the attentiveness that we received. I would highly recommend Selzer Insurance. -Sports and Back Rehabilitation

  • Sean Sullivan
    This is a family business at it's finest!

    “I’ve had liability insurance with Erie for about 6 years now. The Selzer’s recently took over the Kotz’s office, and I couldn’t be happier with their level of customer service! Mike Selzer runs a tight ship. His wife Reenie moved mountains for me when it came to getting Erie to write my worker’s comp policy. I can’t thank them both enough. This is a family business at it’s finest!”

  • Angie Moorhead
    Best most honest insurance company I have ever had !
  • Joe Dowd
    Good folks. Very knowledgeable and friendly. We highly recommend them.
  • Michelle Miller
    5 stars!
  • Desiree Kennedy
    If you're looking for a great insurance company, give them a call!

    “Selzer Insurance is great and they really care about the people they work with. Definitely talk to Michelle if you call and need anything. She is so nice and really helps those who need answers. If you’re looking for a great insurance company, give them a call!”

  • Karen Moorhead Dolton
    Wonderful family business.

    “Wonderful family business. People who always give their customers the best service.”

  • Lauren Burt Ziel
    Top notch, personal service from people who really care about their customers.

    “Top notch, personal service from people who really care about their customers. Combined with fantastic rates, it’s a win-win with Selzer!”